Tuesday , May 24 2022
Home / Project Syndicate / Nation-Building 101

Nation-Building 101

Summary:
Nation-building boils down to “expanding the circle” of moral concern. That is why successful nation-states – large or small, rich or poor – have one thing in common: citizens’ sense of a shared past and future. LONDON – In the aftermath of the Afghanistan debacle, some claim that Western forces might have succeeded had they just come out of the bunker and engaged more with local groups. Others claim that, in the absence of the civic habits and culture of cooperation required by a functioning state, all efforts at nation-building in places like Afghanistan are destined to fail. Both positions are misleading, if not mistaken. China's Risky Business Crackdown Qilai Shen/In

Topics:
Andres Velasco considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Sam Abbott writes Child care costs are going to rise, but policymakers can help U.S. families manage these increases

Peter J. Fugiel writes New research shows unstable schedules do not offer more flexibility for U.S. workers

Simon Wren-lewis writes When did things go wrong, 2010 or 1979?

FT Alphaville writes Further reading

Nation-building boils down to “expanding the circle” of moral concern. That is why successful nation-states – large or small, rich or poor – have one thing in common: citizens’ sense of a shared past and future.

LONDON – In the aftermath of the Afghanistan debacle, some claim that Western forces might have succeeded had they just come out of the bunker and engaged more with local groups. Others claim that, in the absence of the civic habits and culture of cooperation required by a functioning state, all efforts at nation-building in places like Afghanistan are destined to fail. Both positions are misleading, if not mistaken.

Exhibit A in the case against the skeptics is that nations have been built, and not just in homogeneous societies like Japan or Scandinavia. India constructed a vibrant democracy despite a traumatic partition, continent-like size, and a plethora of languages and ethnicities. Brazil has a strong national identity and functioning democratic institutions despite sharp income inequality and deep regional and ethnic cleavages. The United States pulled itself together after a civil war that killed one American in 40.

But those three examples are also Exhibit A in the case against the pollyannas: nation-building is no task for foreigners. One would be hard-pressed to find a historical example of a functioning and cohesive nation-state being imported at the barrel of a gun. Mahatma Gandhi, Abraham Lincoln, and Brazilian democrats like Fernando Henrique Cardoso were not just locals; they...

Andres Velasco
Papá orgulloso de Rosa, Ema y Gaspar y feliz marido de @consuelosaav. Embajador @Hay_Mujeres

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *