Thursday , February 27 2020
Home / Offsetting Behaviour / Creating urban commons problems

Creating urban commons problems

Summary:
If you weren't already familiar with the 9th Circuit ruling in City of Boise vs Martin, and you've been aghast at the stories coming out of San Francisco, you might want to read this LA Times piece by the Manhattan Institute's Stephen Eide.  On Monday, the Supreme Court announced it would not review City of Boise vs. Martin, a 2018 ruling handed down by the San Francisco-based 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. In Martin, the appeals court struck down prohibitions on sleeping and camping in public that the Idaho city had enacted to address homelessness. Boise’s ordinances did not pass constitutional muster, according to the 9th Circuit, because they inflicted “cruel and unusual punishment” on that city’s homeless population.By allowing Martin to stand, the Supreme Court leaves local

Topics:
Eric Crampton considers the following as important: ,

This could be interesting, too:

John H. Cochrane writes Supply and demand in local economics

Eric Crampton writes Routing around the regulatory damage

John H. Cochrane writes Housing hope

Eric Crampton writes Reader mailbag: Weird urban planning edition

If you weren't already familiar with the 9th Circuit ruling in City of Boise vs Martin, and you've been aghast at the stories coming out of San Francisco, you might want to read this LA Times piece by the Manhattan Institute's Stephen Eide
On Monday, the Supreme Court announced it would not review City of Boise vs. Martin, a 2018 ruling handed down by the San Francisco-based 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. In Martin, the appeals court struck down prohibitions on sleeping and camping in public that the Idaho city had enacted to address homelessness. Boise’s ordinances did not pass constitutional muster, according to the 9th Circuit, because they inflicted “cruel and unusual punishment” on that city’s homeless population.

By allowing Martin to stand, the Supreme Court leaves local officials powerless to stop the expansion of homeless encampments. In many West Coast cities, the burgeoning number of tents have left sidewalks in some neighborhoods awash in trash, human waste and used needles and have led to outbreaks of infectious diseases such as hepatitis A and C and rodent infestations.

But as notorious as the homeless crises of Los Angeles and San Francisco are, the consequences of the Martin ruling are most ominous for cities like Boise.

It's well worth reading the whole thing. I hadn't known that New York is now spending over $3 billion annually on homeless services. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *