Thursday , July 18 2019
Home / Jared Bernstein: On the economy / Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

Summary:
Got a late start this AM, so just highlights for now, with more analysis to come. Outliers happen! Payrolls rose a mere 20K last month, a huge downside outlier given the recent trends as shown below in our monthly smoother. The average over the past 3-months of 186K is a much more reliable take on the current underlying pace of job growth. Consider, for example, that payroll jobs were up 311K last month, a value well above trend. So, at least for now, consider this downside miss payback for last month’s huge upside. Of course, the 20K could be harbinger of a downshifting in the pace of payroll job growth. Such a downshift–though not of that magnitude–is not unexpected given a number of facts: job growth slows as we close in on full capacity in the labor market; US GDP is slowing as fiscal

Topics:
Jared Bernstein considers the following as important:

This could be interesting, too:

Jared Bernstein writes No question, the unemployment rate paints an incomplete picture…and yet…

Jared Bernstein writes Judy Shelton and her sponsor—President Trump—want to tie the hands of the Fed

Jared Bernstein writes Why a Fed rate cut makes sense

Jared Bernstein writes More evidence–this time from CBO–that higher (even much higher) minimum wages largely do what they’re supposed to do.

Got a late start this AM, so just highlights for now, with more analysis to come.

Outliers happen!

Payrolls rose a mere 20K last month, a huge downside outlier given the recent trends as shown below in our monthly smoother. The average over the past 3-months of 186K is a much more reliable take on the current underlying pace of job growth. Consider, for example, that payroll jobs were up 311K last month, a value well above trend. So, at least for now, consider this downside miss payback for last month’s huge upside.

Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

Of course, the 20K could be harbinger of a downshifting in the pace of payroll job growth. Such a downshift–though not of that magnitude–is not unexpected given a number of facts: job growth slows as we close in on full capacity in the labor market; US GDP is slowing as fiscal stimulus fades (the tax cuts were a sugar high; not a trickle-down miracle); global growth has slowed; the trade deficit–a drag on growth–has increased in recent quarters.

But one month does not a new trend make and it is too soon to tell whether a new trend is underway.

Then there’s the Household Survey

The survey of households, from which the jobless rate is derived, is telling a different story, one more consistent with the trend conditions in the job market (some of these results are bounceback from January’s gov’t shutdown). The unemployment rate ticked down to 3.8 percent and not because people left the labor market (the participation rate was unchanged) but because the unemployed got jobs (employment rose 255,000 in this survey). There was a large, shutdown-related reversal in involuntary part-time work; unemployment for high-school dropouts hit a near-all-time low of 5.3 percent (it was 5 percent last July), suggesting robust labor demand in the low-wage labor market (a key theme of my work in this area is the extent to which persistently tight labor markets help the least advantaged); and the broader underemployment measure (U-6) also fell to a cyclical low of 7.3 percent.

Finally, decent wage growth, nominal and real

The figures show annual changes in nominal hourly wages for all private-sector workers and for the 80 percent who are production, non-supervisors (think “middle-wage workers”), with 6-month moving averages. The story here is that after being stuck at 2.5 percent for a patch around 2017, the tighter job market began to deliver more bargaining power to wage earners, and firms have had to bid wages up, such that hourly pay is now rising about a point faster than it was back then.

Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

Because topline inflation has been held back by low energy prices, the next figure shows a beneficent collision between faster nominal pay and slower price growth, the difference being real earnings growth. I estimate that the CPI for February rose 1.6 percent. If I’m right, real hourly pay for middle-wage workers is up almost 2 percent, a solid pace for real wages that will boost the buying power of working households.

Jobs report, Feb 2019 [truncated]: Outliers happen, and faster real wage growth!

I’m going to jump for now but will be back soon with some compelling figures (if one can say so ones self) showing how low unemployment is boosting wage growth, but faster wage growth is not juicing price growth.

Jared Bernstein
Jared Bernstein joined the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities in May 2011 as a Senior Fellow. From 2009 to 2011, Bernstein was the Chief Economist and Economic Adviser to Vice President Joe Biden, Executive Director of the White House Task Force on the Middle Class, and a member of President Obama’s economic team. Prior to joining the Obama administration, Bernstein was a senior economist and the director of the Living Standards Program at the Economic Policy Institute, and between 1995 and 1996, he held the post of Deputy Chief Economist at the U.S. Department of Labor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *