Thursday , December 14 2017
Home / Econbrowser - James Hamilton / Beware the State Level Household Employment Series: Wisconsin Edition

Beware the State Level Household Employment Series: Wisconsin Edition

Summary:
Steve Kopits obsesses on the household survey based employment series for Wisconsin, despite our previous exchange on why reliance on this series for Kansas is a problem. But just to make matters concrete, lets look at a few vintages of the household series. Figure 1: Civilian employment from HOUSEHOLD survey in Wisconsin, from December 2015 release (blue), November 2016 release (red), June 2017 release (green), and nonfarm payroll employment from ESTABLISHMENT survey June 2017 release (black), all seasonally adjusted. Source: BLS. As can be seen, there is wide variation in the estimated civilian employment over the various releases. The establishment series exhibits much less variation over releases at the state level, particularly smaller states. The reasons why this is true was

Topics:
Menzie Chinn considers the following as important: ,

This could be interesting, too:

shamyshabeer writes Automatic Job Storm Coming

Menzie Chinn writes Wisconsin Output since Implementation of the MAC

Menzie Chinn writes Where’s the Wisconsin Manufacturing Output Renaissance?

Menzie Chinn writes Tracking Wisconsin Manufacturing Employment

Steve Kopits obsesses on the household survey based employment series for Wisconsin, despite our previous exchange on why reliance on this series for Kansas is a problem. But just to make matters concrete, lets look at a few vintages of the household series.

Beware the State Level Household Employment Series: Wisconsin Edition

Figure 1: Civilian employment from HOUSEHOLD survey in Wisconsin, from December 2015 release (blue), November 2016 release (red), June 2017 release (green), and nonfarm payroll employment from ESTABLISHMENT survey June 2017 release (black), all seasonally adjusted. Source: BLS.

As can be seen, there is wide variation in the estimated civilian employment over the various releases. The establishment series exhibits much less variation over releases at the state level, particularly smaller states. The reasons why this is true was discussed by Justin Wolfers, with special reference to unemployment rates.

Bottom line: Know your data.

Menzie Chinn
He is Professor of Public Affairs and Economics at the University of Wisconsin, Madison

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *