Friday , June 5 2020
Home / Casey Mulligan: Supply and Demand / What’s Wrong with this Reasoning?

What’s Wrong with this Reasoning?

Summary:
FACT: the population density of NYC is 27K per square mile FACT: the population density of Indianapolis is 2K per square mile FACT: COVID-19 was able to be introduced and spread in a city with only 2K susceptible people per square mile (Indianapolis is such a city). Conclusion: COVID-19 will continue to spread in NYC until either (i) the number of susceptible people falls to 2K per square mile or (ii) a vaccine.  i.e., until more than 90% of NYC has contracted and recovered from COVID-19.  [This conclusion says nothing about time frame; i.e., it could be years] Does the conclusion follow from the three facts?

Topics:
[email protected] (Casey B. Mulligan) considers the following as important: ,

This could be interesting, too:

rvohra writes Testing Alone is Insufficient

[email protected] (Casey B. Mulligan) writes Measuring Employment between Monthly Surveys

[email protected] (Casey B. Mulligan) writes Show us the fevers

[email protected] (Casey B. Mulligan) writes 30+ million out of a job


  1. FACT: the population density of NYC is 27K per square mile
  2. FACT: the population density of Indianapolis is 2K per square mile
  3. FACT: COVID-19 was able to be introduced and spread in a city with only 2K susceptible people per square mile (Indianapolis is such a city).
Conclusion: COVID-19 will continue to spread in NYC until either (i) the number of susceptible people falls to 2K per square mile or (ii) a vaccine.  i.e., until more than 90% of NYC has contracted and recovered from COVID-19.  [This conclusion says nothing about time frame; i.e., it could be years]

Does the conclusion follow from the three facts?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *